Archive for the ‘Reviews’ Category

Magnificent Mandeville

Mandeville: A novel of the Wars of the Roses by Christopher Rae

As the world best selling author Bernard Cornwell said, the job of a writer of historical fiction “is not to educate the reader on the finer points of Elizabethan diplomacy or Napoleonic warfare or villainous terrorist plots, your job is to divert and amuse people who have had a hard day at work……your job is not to be a historian but a storyteller.”  Mr. Rae hits the nail bang on the head with a racy plot set against the backdrop of the dramatic Wars of the Roses.  The hero John Mandeville, bent on revenge for the murder of his wife, embarks on a perilous journey to trace her killers.  Little does he know what a hornet’s nest he is about to stirr up, with far-reaching implications for the security of the kingdom.  There are some entertaining vignettes from real historical characters in the novel and whilst we only see the Earl of Warwick from afar, there is a nice twist to his character which leaves the reader aghast.
So, this e-book is a real old-fashioned page-turner that you simply have to download.

Fortress Cornwell

THE FORT. Author: Bernard Cornwell

Some bestselling authors, turned and roasted on the spit of deadlines and commercialism, produce formulaic and cliched work, to the extent that you can almost write the plot and guess the dialogue yourself.  Not so, Bernard Cornwell.  Remove the authors name from the book cover, and you may be forgiven for thinking that the work was not written by him.  The only constant identifiable thread is that this is a damn good piece of historical writing, thoroughly researched.
There is no great pre-amble to this little known episode of the American Revolutionary encounter at Fort George in the unpronouncable Majabigwaduce Peninsula in Massachusetts, but within a few pages we are straight into the conflict and one wonders how he can keep the ante going for 490 pages.  But keep it going he does, in this real page-turner of a book that you will have difficulty putting down, so, be warned.
The story revolves around a community that is ostensibly loyal to British rule but does have a few Revolutionary sympathisers.  The British Brigadier-General, Francis MacLean, supported by the raw but talented Lieutenant John Moore provide the real drive to the storyline whilst the Americans come across as enthusiastic but shambolic, save a few exceptions.  Cornwell includes the iconic Colonel Paul Revere in the story but gradually debunks the popular myth, generally held by many, and gradually reveals him to be a largely untalented, arrogant an unlikeable character.
Whilst a resounding British victory makes no material difference to the outcome of the American Revolution, in the epilogue Cornwell points out that the loss of the thirteen British colonies was more down to French assistance on a grand scale, rather than any particular prowess on the part of the Americans.  I am sure this will create consternation with many of my American cousins, if ever they stumble across this.
In summary, a book you can actually lose yourself in and forget about the worries of the world for a while.  Thoroughly recommended.

 

Bluff and double bluff

PERKIN – A Story of Deception.   Author: Ann Wroe

In terms of an academic piece of historical research this work cannot be faulted.  The thing that left me somewhat disappointed after reading 473 pages was that I was none the wiser as to whether young Perkin was real or fake.  It was a bit like reading a Sherlock Holmes novel and finishing the final chapter without understanding who the perpetrator of the crime was.
This does not detract from a very well researched book with lots of reference to original sources.  Ann Wroe really gets into the mind of Henry Tudor and we see how he operates; paranoia about the threat that Perkin poses, yes, but also how cautious and canny he is about his ensnarement and downfall.  It’s amazing to think how much trouble a commoner caused a king.
My main purpose in buying the book was to understand the role that Sir Robert Clifford played in this plot and in that, the author goes into great detail.  The only observation I would make is that she falls into the trap of many historians, and misunderstands why he was prepared to be implicated and then reconciled. The answer is quite simple, Clifford wanted to wreak revenge on his family’s sworn enemy, Sir William Stanley, and he brings about his downfall in a dramatic and masterful fashion.
In my opinion, for what it is worth, I think Perkin was the son of a Flemish boatman and not the long-lost Richard, Duke of York.  But whoever he was, he certainly caused many a sleepless night for the newly crowned Tudor monarch, and Ann Wroe conveys that with aplomb.

Flodden, then and now

You will never learn all there is to know about battles by sticking your head in a book; you need to get out there and see the battlefield for yourself.  The high bluffs, the snaking rivers and seemingly impassable fords.  The lie of the land, the boggy marsh and the exact spot where the doomed heroes fell and the victors claimed their spoils.

There is one step better though and that’s walking the terrain with an expert guide; precisely what happens when you put the Flodden DVD into your player and click the “OK” button.

Clive Hallam-Baker takes you on a shadowy journey into the past, against a backdrop of scenery that has hardly changed since that fateful day on 9th September 1513 when brave men fought hand to hand and fourteen thousand died in the space of a few hours, at the Battle of Flodden field.

Amazing cinematography and a great soundtrack help set the scene for a fascinating encounter between two old foes.  King James IV of Scotland is caught on the
horns of a dilemma.  Does he obey the treaty of Perpetual Peace with his English neighbours, or is the pull of the Auld Alliance with France too strong when his brother-in-law Henry VIII attacks the French kingdom?  Hallam-Baker really captures the mood of the time when he tells of the English king’s parting shot to the Earl off Surrey, “trust not the Scots” as he embarks across the channel, leaving the defence of his realm to the wily old commander.

What follows, as they say, is history. Assisted by James Bell of the Flodden 1513 Club and one of the North’s most prolific and talented authors, John Sadler, our chronicler paints a vivid picture of the events and tactics preceding the battle.  Like a scout from an old Hollywood Western, Hallam-Baker has the knack of making you feel like you were actually there, as he traces the routes of both armies across a hostile terrain, long disputed and fiercely contested by English and Scots alike.

A romantic but futile act of bravery concludes the story and precipitates the death of the last British monarch on a field of battle, when James IV is hacked to death fighting shoulder to shoulder with his loyal followers.  Was there a winner?  Henry VIII could hardly claim victory as he was away in France and ironically, the English lion and theScottish unicorn were soon to be united a generation or so later when James VI of Scotland ascended the throne as James I of England, following the expiration of the Tudor line.

This masterful work is dedicated to the brave men of both sides, who fought an epic battle on that day.

Masterly Rendition of a Medieval Mindset

Despite being a technophobe, this publication intrigued me so much, I was
inspired to buy a Kindle just so I could read this book. Was it worth it? Well,
in my opinion this is one of the best novels produced in a decade - across all
genres. It tells the story of Richard III’s asecent to the throne, in the first
person narrative of one of his friends, Francis Lovell. But it’s not what you
might assume, and the story twists and turns so that you are left wondering in
what direction the plot will go next. The author has gone to great pains to
research the life and times of England’s most iconic and controversial monarch
but in the style of all good novelists, has imposed his own stamp on the theme.
I cannot think that anyone who reads this novel will be disappointed. Well done,
Mr. Rae. And as for the Kindle….. it didn’t take long to get used to it and
I’ve now downloaded several more books.

London’s Burning – Great Balls Of Fire!

I had quite forgotten what a fascinating lifespan Samuel Pepys had until I
recently re-read this book on holiday. The execution of King Charles I,
Cromwell’s ascendancy, the Restoration, the Great Fire of London, the Dutch
Wars. It has it all! The best aspect of the book though, is Claire Tomalin’s
portrayal of Pepys in a truly intimate fashion – she brings the narrative from
his diaries alive; his fears, his doubts, his romances, his smooth transition
from Parliamentarian to staunch king’s man. One cannot but wonder about the
powerful skills of observation from this fascinating character, as he strolls
through rioting Londoners and keeps a watching brief on the fire that engulfed
the City, so that he can record the outcome for contemporary reports and for
posterity. The reader is left with a sympathetic view of this extraordinary man
who rose to prominence from very ordinary circumstances. What brought the story
home to me was the reluctance of the nation to publish the diaries in a complete
and unabridged fashion for centuries. It just goes to show that Publishers have
ever been slow off the mark to realise real talent.

Fatal Colours by George Goodwin

Fatal Colours

5 out of 5 stars

I was recently privileged to get an advance copy of this from the Publishers so that I could preparea review.  It will soon be generally  available and can be pre-ordered on Amazon.

The Battle of Towton holds a fascination for many authors and the books currently available, several by established Towton Battlefield Society members, rate high in the Amazon worldwide rankings.  So, why would you buy Fatal Colours when so much has been written about Towton before?  Surely, every source document has been pored over, every contour of the landscape has been observed, every archaeological find has been analysed by experts to bring up clues as to why this battle was the bloodiest in our nation’s history?

Well, in this book,, George Goodwin does not attempt to outmuscle the iconic works of others, he takes a different slant, delving into his far-reaching and incisive knowledge of history.  His approach is one of setting the scene to explain the peculiar circumstances that led to this catastrophic encounter on Palm Sunday in 1461 and he does it with great style and aplomb. I believe that the mark of a good writer is the ability to make the vastly complex appear simple and logical, and George achieves this in spades. For me, reading this book was like looking into a prism to view the multi-faceted machinations of the late medieval period.  He analyses the cause and effect of poor Henry VI’s schizophrenic behaviour, he portrays Warwick as the “spin doctor” for the House of York, he explains how this battle had pivoted into a North-South divide and he places the conflict at Towton in an international context.

All of this is done in an extremely readable style and there are many quotable gems; my particular favourite being “The law is like a Welshman’s hose; it is the right shape for each man’s leg.  So supporters twist it and its might is crushed under foot.” George skilfully uses recorded excerpts like this to explain the dichotomy that the nation faced at the time.  Did one support the anointed King and let misrule continue or did one follow the reforming zeal of the Yorkists?

I’m not a gambling man but I’ll bet the farm on this being a best seller, especially with this year being the 550th anniversary of Towton.

John Rolfe of Virginia by James Tormey

John Rolfe

4out of 5 stars

Forget the Pilgrim Fathers, that’s just Puritan propaganda – John Rolfe settled in the New World well before them and carved out a life for himself through a combination of intuition, hard work and dogged determination.
This fascinating book plots the birth of the Colony of Virginia and gives a fascinating insight into how the early settlers battled against the elements, famine, fierce Indians and naivety in a hostile landscape. Initially led by an incompetent ruling class, the Colony was saved by the arrival of more practical men who put some steel into the settlers and under whom Rolfe thrived.
This remarkable man went on to grow a strain of tobacco that was so successful that it became a staple for trading with England and then married the Indian Princess Pocahontas, despite not having the approval of England’s King James I.
The only downside to the book for me was that the author could have raised the ante with his prose during the more dramatic scenes but nonetheless, this is a must-read book with many entertaining revelations.

Outlaw by Angus Donald

Outlaw

4 out of 5 stars

Like a lot of people I was intrigued by the sticker “As good as Bernard Cornwell or your money back.” As a marketing ploy, it certainly works. Was it is as good? Will I be asking for my money back? Well, it was different. I have to say that as a novel, it was very entertaining – once I picked it up, I didn’t want to put it down. The only real disappointment for me was that it was a tad cliched in the way it followed the traditional Robin Hood legend – I thought there was more scope for being a bit inventive. The authentic “Yorkshire” Robin Hood character has been pinched by a Medieval Brian Clough and to this day, we all picture the outlaw’s base in Nottinghamshire rather than Yorkshire. I thought the book could have followed this theme and therefore have more historical accuracy.
I am being picky though, as a compelling read, it certainly worked for me and I will definitely be buying this author’s next book.

Towton: The Bloodiest Battle by Andrew Boardman

Towton Book Boardman

5 out of 5 stars

Whilst I have said in the heading that, in my opinion, this is a definitive book on the Battle of Towton, I feel it is much more than that. It gives real clarity to the wider conflict of the Wars of the Roses, a very complex and involved period of English history. Full of well researched facts and fascinating illustrations and maps, it is a “must” read for anyone interested in medieval history. What really impressed me about Mr. Boardman was his complete impartiality and balance in describing the rival factions of Lancaster and York – normally when one reads these types of work, the author’s bias comes through. Added to that, an interesting style of prose that made me feel it was a “page-turner” novel, rather than a factual history book. I finished the book within two days so complete was my absorption in it.